I did it — I read J.K. Rowling’s TALES OF BEEDLE THE BARD. I knew it wouldn’t be another Harry Potter book. I knew it would just re-open the gaping hole left by the completion of the Harry Potter series. But I read it anyway, and it was predictably meh. I found the stories boring, although I’ve never been one for fairy tales of any kind, so others may have liked them more. The “commentaries” by Dumbledore were entirely predictable, didn’t say much, and were interpreting stories with pretty simple morals to begin with. BUT…it was Dumbledore again, a little slice of him brought back to life to say a few new things. His voice, his style, his funny, almost snide asides about the stupidity and silliness of certain historical wizards and the unkind accusations in Lucius Malfoy’s old letters. And so, while it’s a boring, predictable, not-quite-worth-it book, its also a reminder of the incredible characters J.K. Rowling gave us in Harry Potter — characters I love so much that it was a joy to have one of them back, alive and speaking, for a few more pages.
-->Feed me text
January 27, 2009 at 11:27 am
This is sort of how I felt about RAMONA’s WORLD. Well, first I just felt keen disappointment. It is not a good book. But still… Ramona!!!!!!
January 27, 2009 at 10:12 pm
This is a good summation of how I approached and reacted to Lyra’s Oxford. Cool blog guys.
January 29, 2009 at 9:06 am
Thanks, Stephen. Good call on LYRA’s OXFORD, I felt that too – an enjoyable use of an hour of reading time, but I was glad I hadn’t spent money on it, and while I’ll continue to read the HIS DARK MATERIALS trilogy over and over, I’ll probably never pick up LYRA’s OXFORD again.
February 1, 2010 at 2:26 am
i have read your some of your posts . i have not found a single post in which you are saying that omg this book is good and this is worth reading . is there any book you really like. if somebody is using your reviews to choose a book they are making the biggest mistake of their life. heck with you